make sure: - in the profile, that policyset.caCertSet.list has p7 - the CA was restarted after the custom profile changes - a review of the CA debug log, the profile you modified should be listed after a restart as, for example: [14/Feb/2019:00:30:49][localhost-startStop-1]: added plugin profile caServerCertEnrollImpl Server Certificate Enrollment Profile Certificate Authority Server Certificate Enrollment Profile com.netscape.cms.profile.common.ServerCertCAEnrollProfile [14/Feb/2019:00:31:43][localhost-startStop-1]: added plugin profile caServerCertEnrollImpl Server Certificate Enrollment Profile Certificate Authority Server Certificate Enrollment Profile com.netscape.cms.profile.common.ServerCertCAEnrollProfile [14/Feb/2019:00:31:45][localhost-startStop-1]: Start Profile Creation - caServerCert caEnrollImpl com.netscape.cms.profile.common.CAEnrollProfile [14/Feb/2019:00:31:45][localhost-startStop-1]: Done Profile Creation - caServerCert [14/Feb/2019:00:31:45][localhost-startStop-1]: Registered Confirmation - caServerCert and between the "Start" and "Done", there should be the details of the profile, with string "BasicProfile: createProfilePolicy" and more info - review the same debug log after enrollment, for more details. Thanks, Marc S. On Tue, Apr 23, 2019 at 9:23 PM Jonathan Montero <jmrxto(a)gmail.com&gt; wrote: > Hi, I'm having an issue regarding the certificates policies. > > It is as follows... > policyset.caCertSet.p7.constraint.class_id=noConstraintImpl > policyset.caCertSet.p7.constraint.name=No Constraint > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.class_id=certificatePoliciesExtDefaultImpl > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.name=Certificate Policies Extension > Default > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.Critical=true > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.num=1 > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.enable=true > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.enable=true > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.value= > http://url.com/ > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.enable=true > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.explicitText.value=Some > Text Here > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.noticeNumbers=1 > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.organization=Company > text Here > > > So, with this configuration i got not all the result i want, don't know > why.... > > i obtain > policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 > > Also > CPSURI.value=http://url.com/ > > But can't get the explicitText.value and organization... > > For some reason, those 2 latter options don't appear in the certificate. > > What could this be? > > > > > Jonathan Montero > > IT Professional | IT Trainer > M: 809-609-3003 > S: tuxmontero > E: jmrxto(a)gmail.com > A: Santo Domingo, DR > > jonathanmontero.com > > <https://www.linkedin.com/in/monterojonathan> > <https://twitter.com/tuxmontero> <https://www.facebook.com/jmrxto> > <https://github.com/tuxmontero> > > _______________________________________________ > Pki-users mailing list > Pki-users(a)redhat.com > https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/pki-users

I see nothing that seem incorrect in your configurations, I will try a test, meanwhile, could you indicate the exact RHEL or Fedora versions and rpm -q pki-ca ? and are there any other related debug log entries? (like about PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.enable ) Thanks, M. On Wed, Apr 24, 2019 at 10:19 AM Jonathan Montero <jmrxto(a)gmail.com&gt; wrote: > Hi, thanks for your answer > > - in the profile, that policyset.caCertSet.list has p7 > *DONE* > - the CA was restarted after the custom profile changes *DONE* > - debug log *DONE?* > [24/Apr/2019:12:45:33][http-bio-8443-exec-1]: RequestProcessor: > profileId=caClase1 > [24/Apr/2019:12:46:29][localhost-startStop-1]: Start Profile Creation - > caClase1 caEnrollImpl com.netscape.cms.profile.common.CAEnrollProfile > [24/Apr/2019:12:46:29][localhost-startStop-1]: Done Profile Creation - > caClase1 > [24/Apr/2019:12:46:29][localhost-startStop-1]: Registered Confirmation - > caClase1 > > Also looked for more logs... > I see and XML section for some reason i see this in the XML > <description>This default populates a Certificate Policies Extension to > the request. The default values are Criticality=true, > {PoliciesExt.num:1,{Enable:true,Policy > Id:1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1,PolicyQualifiers.num:,{CPSuri > Enable:true,UserNotice Enable:true,UserNoticeReference Organization:Company > text Here,UserNoticeReference Numbers:1,UserNoticeReference Explicit > Text:Some Text Here,CPS uri:http://url.com/}}}</description> > > *BUTTTTT, if i go down in the file i see* > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.enable:true&#xD; > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.policyId:1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1&#xD; > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers.num:1&#xD; > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.enable:true&#xD; > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.value: > http://url.com/&#xD; > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.enable:*false*&#xD; > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.organization:&#xD; > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.noticeNumbers:&#xD; > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.explicitText.value:&#xD; > > *The last 3 lines are EMPTY.* > > > Jonathan Montero > > IT Professional | IT Trainer > M: 809-609-3003 > S: tuxmontero > E: jmrxto(a)gmail.com > A: Santo Domingo, DR > > jonathanmontero.com > > <https://www.linkedin.com/in/monterojonathan> > <https://twitter.com/tuxmontero> <https://www.facebook.com/jmrxto> > <https://github.com/tuxmontero> > > > > On Wed, Apr 24, 2019 at 12:26 PM Marc Sauton <msauton(a)redhat.com&gt; wrote: > >> make sure: >> - in the profile, that policyset.caCertSet.list has p7 >> - the CA was restarted after the custom profile changes >> - a review of the CA debug log, the profile you modified should be >> listed after a restart as, for example: >> [14/Feb/2019:00:30:49][localhost-startStop-1]: added plugin profile >> caServerCertEnrollImpl Server Certificate Enrollment Profile Certificate >> Authority Server Certificate Enrollment Profile >> com.netscape.cms.profile.common.ServerCertCAEnrollProfile >> [14/Feb/2019:00:31:43][localhost-startStop-1]: added plugin profile >> caServerCertEnrollImpl Server Certificate Enrollment Profile Certificate >> Authority Server Certificate Enrollment Profile >> com.netscape.cms.profile.common.ServerCertCAEnrollProfile >> [14/Feb/2019:00:31:45][localhost-startStop-1]: Start Profile Creation - >> caServerCert caEnrollImpl com.netscape.cms.profile.common.CAEnrollProfile >> [14/Feb/2019:00:31:45][localhost-startStop-1]: Done Profile Creation - >> caServerCert >> [14/Feb/2019:00:31:45][localhost-startStop-1]: Registered Confirmation - >> caServerCert >> and between the "Start" and "Done", there should be the details of the >> profile, with string "BasicProfile: createProfilePolicy" and more info >> - review the same debug log after enrollment, for more details. >> Thanks, >> Marc S. >> >> On Tue, Apr 23, 2019 at 9:23 PM Jonathan Montero <jmrxto(a)gmail.com&gt; >> wrote: >> >>> Hi, I'm having an issue regarding the certificates policies. >>> >>> It is as follows... >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.constraint.class_id=noConstraintImpl >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.constraint.name=No Constraint >>> >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.class_id=certificatePoliciesExtDefaultImpl >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.name=Certificate Policies Extension >>> Default >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.Critical=true >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.num=1 >>> >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.enable=true >>> >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 >>> >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.enable=true >>> >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.value= >>> http://url.com/ >>> >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.enable=true >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.explicitText.value=Some >>> Text Here >>> >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.noticeNumbers=1 >>> policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.organization=Company >>> text Here >>> >>> >>> So, with this configuration i got not all the result i want, don't know >>> why.... >>> >>> i obtain >>> policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 >>> >>> Also >>> CPSURI.value=http://url.com/ >>> >>> But can't get the explicitText.value and organization... >>> >>> For some reason, those 2 latter options don't appear in the certificate. >>> >>> What could this be? >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> Jonathan Montero >>> >>> IT Professional | IT Trainer >>> M: 809-609-3003 >>> S: tuxmontero >>> E: jmrxto(a)gmail.com >>> A: Santo Domingo, DR >>> >>> jonathanmontero.com >>> >>> <https://www.linkedin.com/in/monterojonathan> >>> <https://twitter.com/tuxmontero> <https://www.facebook.com/jmrxto> >>> <https://github.com/tuxmontero> >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Pki-users mailing list >>> Pki-users(a)redhat.com >>> https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/pki-users >> >>

On Wed, Apr 24, 2019 at 12:21:23AM -0400, Jonathan Montero wrote: > Hi, I'm having an issue regarding the certificates policies. > > It is as follows... > policyset.caCertSet.p7.constraint.class_id=noConstraintImpl > policyset.caCertSet.p7.constraint.name=No Constraint > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.class_id=certificatePoliciesExtDefaultImpl > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.name=Certificate Policies Extension Default > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.Critical=true > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.num=1 > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.enable=true > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.enable=true > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.value= > http://url.com/ > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.enable=true > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.explicitText.value=Some > Text Here > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.noticeNumbers=1 > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.organization=Company > text Here > > > So, with this configuration i got not all the result i want, don't know > why.... > > i obtain > policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 > > Also > CPSURI.value=http://url.com/ > > But can't get the explicitText.value and organization... > > For some reason, those 2 latter options don't appear in the certificate. > > What could this be? > Dogtag cert policies config is very unfriendly. Without having confirmed, I'm pretty sure you need something like: PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.enable=true PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers.num=2 PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.enable=true PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.value=http://url.com/ PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.enable=true PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.explicitText.value=Some text Here PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.noticeReference.noticeNumbers=1 PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.noticeReference.organization=Company text Here Each policy qualified can be either a CPS URI or a user notice, so if you want both, you need two qualifiers. This is not a restriction in Dogtag, rather it is part of X.509 standard: Qualifier ::= CHOICE { cPSuri CPSuri, userNotice UserNotice } Hope that helps! Cheers, Fraser

There's an error in the configuration, but as pointed out in another branch of the thread there is also a bug with arguement order which is fatal to the UserNotice use case. So that will have to be triaged and fix. I did work out how to include multiple policy qualifiers, though. UserNotice is broken but as an example, here's how to get two URIs (common prefix elided): PoliciesExt.num=1 PolicyQualifiers.num=2 PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.enable=true PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers.num=2 PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.enable=true PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.value=http://foo.com/ PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.enable=false PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.CPSURI.enable=true PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.CPSURI.value=http://bar.com/ PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.enable=false It is necessary to include both CPSURL.enable=bool and usernotice.enable=bool, with CPSURL taking precedence. The PolicyQualifiers.num=N applies to all policies, which is a bug (it prevents defining policies with different numbers of qualifiers). But it is adequate for a single-policy, multiple-qualifier use case. Cheers, Fraser

On Sun, Apr 28, 2019 at 10:52:22PM -0400, Jonathan Montero wrote: > Thanks for your answer, but no, it didn't work... > > i got a java error when i try to approve the certificate, meaning that > something is wrong with the configuration. > > To be a good config i had to take all those 1 to 0 back again. > > > > Jonathan Montero > > IT Professional | IT Trainer > M: 809-609-3003 > S: tuxmontero > E: jmrxto(a)gmail.com > A: Santo Domingo, DR > > jonathanmontero.com > > <https://www.linkedin.com/in/monterojonathan> > <https://twitter.com/tuxmontero> <https://www.facebook.com/jmrxto> > <https://github.com/tuxmontero> > > > > On Sun, Apr 28, 2019 at 9:19 PM Fraser Tweedale <ftweedal(a)redhat.com&gt; wrote: > > > On Wed, Apr 24, 2019 at 12:21:23AM -0400, Jonathan Montero wrote: > > > Hi, I'm having an issue regarding the certificates policies. > > > > > > It is as follows... > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.constraint.class_id=noConstraintImpl > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.constraint.name=No Constraint > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.class_id=certificatePoliciesExtDefaultImpl > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.name=Certificate Policies Extension > > Default > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.Critical=true > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.num=1 > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.enable=true > > > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 > > > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.enable=true > > > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.value= > > > http://url.com/ > > > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.enable=true > > > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.explicitText.value=Some > > > Text Here > > > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.noticeNumbers=1 > > > > > policyset.caCertSet.p7.default.params.PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.usernotice.noticeReference.organization=Company > > > text Here > > > > > > > > > So, with this configuration i got not all the result i want, don't know > > > why.... > > > > > > i obtain > > > policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 > > > > > > Also > > > CPSURI.value=http://url.com/ > > > > > > But can't get the explicitText.value and organization... > > > > > > For some reason, those 2 latter options don't appear in the certificate. > > > > > > What could this be? > > > > > Dogtag cert policies config is very unfriendly. Without having > > confirmed, I'm pretty sure you need something like: > > > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.enable=true > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.policyId=1.3.6.1.4.1.6.1.1.1.1 > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers.num=2 > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.enable=true > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers0.CPSURI.value=http://url.com/ > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.enable=true > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.explicitText.value=Some > > text Here > > > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.noticeReference.noticeNumbers=1 > > PoliciesExt.certPolicy0.PolicyQualifiers1.usernotice.noticeReference.organization=Company > > text Here > > > > Each policy qualified can be either a CPS URI or a user notice, so > > if you want both, you need two qualifiers. This is not a > > restriction in Dogtag, rather it is part of X.509 standard: > > > > > > Qualifier ::= CHOICE { > > cPSuri CPSuri, > > userNotice UserNotice } > > > > Hope that helps! > > > > Cheers, > > Fraser > >