Thanks Endi, nice catch on one missing audit.
Per our discussion on irc, added the missing audit and pushed to master:
c0d14140aca982ac637d5fd34f1c3ddb23836867

And a new ticket created to cover the desirable upgrade script: https://fedorahosted.org/pki/ticket/1382 KRA: upgrade script maybe needed for CS.cfg to add new audit events added in ticket 1160

Christina


On 05/14/2015 01:04 PM, Endi Sukma Dewata wrote:
On 5/13/2015 7:27 PM, Christina Fu wrote:
This patch (pki-cfu-0062) is to replace pki-cfu-0060
after receiving help from Endi on how to test these key options (thanks
Endi!), I have made some code changes for the tests I ran.

Just to show some of the test results:

...key-mod 0x2 --status active yields the following audit messages:
0.http-bio-28443-exec-13 - [13/May/2015:19:04:01 EDT] [14] [6]
[AuditEvent=KEY_STATUS_CHANGE][SubjectID=kraadmin][Outcome=Success][KeyID=3][OldStatus=active][NewStatus=active][Info=KeyService.modifyKeyStatus]
Key Status Change
0.http-bio-28443-exec-14 - [13/May/2015:19:04:02 EDT] [14] [6]
[AuditEvent=SECURITY_DATA_RETRIEVE_KEY][SubjectID=kraadmin][Outcome=Success][RecoveryID=null][KeyID=3][Info=KeyService.getKeyInfo]
security data retrieval request

  key-generate test3 --key-algorithm RSA --key-size 1024 yields the
following audit message:
0.http-bio-28443-exec-19 - [13/May/2015:19:10:24 EDT] [14] [6]
[AuditEvent=ASYMKEY_GENERATION_REQUEST][SubjectID=kraadmin][Outcome=Success][GenerationRequestID=6][ClientKeyID=test3]
Asymkey generation request made
[AuditEvent=ASYMKEY_GENERATION_REQUEST_PROCESSED][SubjectID=kraadmin][Outcome=Success][GenerationRequestID=6][ClientKeyID=test3][KeyID=4][FailureReason=None]
Asymkey generation request processed

key-archive  --clientKeyID test4 --passphrase  "cfu secret" yields the
following audit messages:
0.http-bio-28443-exec-24 - [13/May/2015:19:21:37 EDT] [14] [6]
[AuditEvent=SECURITY_DATA_ARCHIVAL_REQUEST_PROCESSED][SubjectID=kraadmin][Outcome=Success][ArchivalRequestID=7][ClientKeyID=test4][KeyID=5][FailureReason=None]
security data archival request processed
0.http-bio-28443-exec-24 - [13/May/2015:19:21:37 EDT] [14] [6]
[AuditEvent=SECURITY_DATA_ARCHIVAL_REQUEST][SubjectID=kraadmin][Outcome=Success][ArchivalRequestID=7][ClientKeyID=test4]
security data archival request made

thanks,
Christina

Some comments:

1. There should be an upgrade script to update the CS.cfg in existing KRA instances.

2. In KeyService.java:416 the method may return without audit logging.

Everything else looks good.